Silver Hopkins All articles
Leadership & Governance

The Variation File: What Repeated Change Requests Say About How You Commission

Silver Hopkins
The Variation File: What Repeated Change Requests Say About How You Commission

Photo: financial ledger spreadsheet documents desk office analysis, via p16-ehi-va.gauthmath.com

The change request is among the least examined documents in a consultancy engagement. It arrives as a PDF attached to a short email, is approved by whoever holds the budget, is paid, and disappears into the finance system. At year end the advisory spend sits modestly above the figure that was minuted at the outset, and everyone involved has a plausible explanation for the gap.

That is a mistake, and not chiefly a financial one. Every variation is a data point about the quality of the original commission — the brief, the sponsor, the assumptions, the price. One variation is an event. Six, spread across three suppliers, is a finding about the client.

Why variations vanish from oversight

Variations are approved at a level below the board because each is individually small. A three-day extension for stakeholder interviews, a fifth workshop, an additional legal read of the final report: none of these, alone, merits a governance conversation. Cumulatively they can add a fifth to the fee and a month to the timetable, and they can shift the shape of the advice itself, since extra work tends to concentrate on whichever part of the brief the client found most uncomfortable.

The structure of most engagement letters encourages this. Variation clauses are drafted to be quick and permissive because both parties want the work to continue without friction. Nobody in the room is responsible for the aggregate.

The ledger, and its four columns

A single page, maintained by whoever owns the advisory budget, is enough. For every variation across every live engagement record four things: what was added or changed; the value and the days; who requested it — supplier or client; and the elapsed time between engagement start and the first variation.

Two derived figures are worth calculating each quarter. The first is variation value as a proportion of original contracted fee, by supplier and across the portfolio. The second is the time to first variation, averaged. Neither needs to be presented with commentary to be useful; the board will read the shape of it.

Three readings of a pattern

The briefing failure

Here variations cluster around interpretation rather than events: scope clarification, rework of a workstream, additional interviews to settle what the question really was. Time to first variation is short. Supplier-initiated variations dominate. The pattern says the brief was ambiguous on deliverables, or that the author of the brief and the person who will use the output held different views and never found out.

The trigger is not a negotiation with the supplier. It is an examination of your own commissioning template: are deliverables described in terms of activity or outcome, and has the actual user of the advice signed the brief?

The moving target

Variations arrive later, cluster around a change of sponsor, a shift in market conditions, or an internal reorganisation, and are client-initiated. The value is often substantial and the pace uneven. This pattern is not necessarily a failure; circumstances move. But it reveals whether anyone has tested the brief against the business environment since it was written, and whether the engagement has a defined point at which the question is formally re-confirmed or closed.

The trigger is governance: a documented review at the natural midpoint, at which continuing, re-scoping and stopping are all genuinely available.

The deliberate underbid

This is the least comfortable reading and should not be reached for too readily. The signs are a conspicuously keen initial price against a comparable market, a tight definition of scope at signature, and a steady stream of variations from the first fortnight that restore the margin. The original proposal was priced to win an award, not to deliver the brief, and the variation clause is doing the work the fee should have done.

Where this reading is supported, the response belongs in the next procurement round rather than in a dispute over the current contract: compare fee plus variations, not fee, when evaluating; ask what the proposal assumes will not be done; and treat a large gap between bid and delivery cost as a question about the bid.

What the ledger changes in the conversation

None of this requires new systems or a change of policy. It requires one artefact, kept consistently, and fifteen minutes at a board or audit committee twice a year.

What it changes is the quality of the question asked at the next appointment. Instead of asking a supplier to justify an increase, the firm can ask itself why its briefs keep producing the same gap. That is a question suppliers cannot answer on the client's behalf, and it is the one that eventually reduces the spend.

The ledger is not a control. It is a mirror, and it is more useful when consulted before the contract than after it.

All Articles

Related Articles

What the Brief Takes for Granted: A Board-Level Audit of Consultancy Problem-Setting

What the Brief Takes for Granted: A Board-Level Audit of Consultancy Problem-Setting

The People They Met: Closing the Talent Gap in UK Consultancy Engagements

The People They Met: Closing the Talent Gap in UK Consultancy Engagements

Who Else Is Listening? The Board's Standing Test for Adviser Conflicts

Who Else Is Listening? The Board's Standing Test for Adviser Conflicts